Keeping Housing Simple | Think Realty Magazine | June 2018
Profiles Master Investors

Keeping Housing Simple

Carrington Holdings’ Rick Sharga is the Voice of Change in Real Estate

For more than 10 years, Rick Sharga has been the voice of change in the real estate industry. That is not something the now-renowned housing and foreclosure expert will ever tell you he saw coming. When Sharga, now executive vice president at Carrington Mortgage Holdings, joined the real estate space in 2004, the national housing market was still going full throttle.

Sharga had spent two decades in marketing before entering the real estate industry: first as a branding expert for technology companies during the dot-com era and then, when that market “imploded,” as he describes it, as an independent consultant.

“We thought technology companies would be our safety net because they were not new, like the internet startups, which had so much risk. That prediction was wrong,” Sharga recalled ruefully. “The tech companies cut their marketing budgets to just about zero when everything collapsed. There were literally no marketing jobs across the country.”

Carrington was founded in 2003 as Carrington Capital Management and grew to manage more than $1 billion in assets in just three years. Today, Carrington companies work in sync to provide nationwide real estate services encompassing nearly all aspects of single-family residential real estate transactions.

Sharga struck out on his own as a consultant with “four or five people from the company,” he said. “RealtyTrac became one of my clients in that practice.”

RealtyTrac (today’s ATTOM Data Solutions) was, at that time, a regional company selling REO leads to local realtors. Later, when RealtyTrac’s CEO wanted to take the company national and, as Sharga described it, “democratize foreclosure data for anyone who was interested in buying those types of properties,” the consultant was clearly a good fit for RealtyTrac’s new vice president of marketing position.

Sharga intended to remain with the new company just long enough to build a marketing department and launch the brand before returning to his consulting practice. Instead, he remained with RealtyTrac and became its primary public voice for the next eight-and-a-half years. During that time, he would become the public’s primary narrator for the mid-2000s housing crash as well.

The Housing Conversation Must be Simple

When the foreclosure crisis overwhelmed the housing market in 2007 and 2008, Sharga found himself squarely in the limelight. His relatively abbreviated background in real estate represented a huge advantage for him professionally.

A branding expert with access to housing data and the ability to put that data and its context into simple terms was just what the entire country needed during the housing meltdown.

“I spoke to reporters in terms that I could understand. As it turned out, that made a complicated process somewhat simple,” Sharga said. In conjunction with his exclusive access to RealtyTrac’s database of foreclosures and the absence of any need for damage control, his profile in the industry and in industry news coverage skyrocketed.

“No one else wanted to talk about the foreclosures that were already happening or the wave that was coming,” Sharga said. “Other parties that might have had similar data to ours, such as lenders and some policy-makers, would not really have benefited from that discussion.” He began receiving high volumes of what he terms “4 a.m. calls” in his California office from East Coast analysts and reporters wanting to know when RealtyTrac data would be released for the day.

“It was a lightning-in-a-bottle moment, and I became a subject-matter expert in foreclosures even before I was a subject-matter expert in broader real estate issues. Analyzing that foreclosure data and the housing crash really was my accidental entry into the world of real estate,” Sharga explained.

He remained at RealtyTrac until 2011, when he took a job with Carrington Holding Company. He helped bring the company’s multiple real estate- and mortgage-related services businesses under one banner and build awareness for the company’s charitable foundation, which supports numerous local and national nonprofits and focuses on assisting wounded veterans and their families.

Sharga departed Carrington in 2013 to work with online auction giant Auction.com and later, its parent company Ten-X. “The idea of being at the leading edge of a technology wave with a company aspiring to become as ubiquitous as eBay in the real estate market was, frankly, very appealing,” he admitted. “It was a very interesting time.”

However, when Ten-X opted to exit the retail side of the housing market, Sharga knew the time had come to return to Carrington. Fortunately for the company, he arrived just in time for one of the most controversial lending announcements to be made since the housing recovery began, when Carrington debuted its “nonprime loan” earlier this year.

Back in the Headlines, Still Keeping Things Simple

Readers will probably not find it surprising that Carrington’s debut of a “nonprime” mortgage loan has been met with mixed responses. The program “looks an awful lot like pre-crisis subprime lending,” snarked one industry publication, while another warned, “[Subprime mortgages] were blamed for the biggest financial disaster in a century.”

Sharga proudly participates in Carrington Charitable Foundation’s support of more than 100 charities, including signature program Veterans Airlift Command, which provides free air transport to post 9/11 combat veterans and their families.

Sharga, true to form, keeps his responses to these criticisms simple and on-point, carefully and patiently explaining the difference between Carrington Mortgage’s nonprime loans and the subprime loans issued prior to the housing crash. “We are not lending to borrowers who have no ‘skin in the game,’ so to speak,” he began.

“We are experts in working with what you might call less-than-perfect borrowers. To a great extent, these are people who would have qualified for a mortgage before the foreclosure crisis. They have traditionally been viewed as creditworthy and would, by and large, have paid their mortgages on time. The difference between today’s loans and what was happening during the early 2000s is simple but vast: We are carefully underwriting every loan and we offset risk. We don’t throw our loans or our borrowers into an app somewhere that is crunching out loans for people who cannot afford them.”

Sharga cited a recent Urban Institute report indicating about 6.3 million borrowers who historically would have qualified for a loan have been denied since 2009 because lenders are, understandably, refusing to take on any perceived risk in their mortgages. “We view this as an opportunity to provide a chance for homeownership and for home investments that otherwise would not exist,” he said, noting Carrington’s highly personalized underwriting process also enables real estate investors to purchase additional properties in many instances.

Carrington’s activities during the downturn also contribute to its confidence in the nonprime lending process today. The company was one of the country’s largest purchasers of non-performing loans during that period “and we managed to get many of those loans re-performing, keeping thousands of borrowers in their homes,” Sharga said proudly. “We believe if you focus on doing three specific things very well, there is very little extra risk in a nonprime loan.”

Here are Sharga’s three must-dos:

One, you need to carefully underwrite the loans. That was the biggest thing missing during the housing boom. Common sense in underwriting tells you if one part of an application looks risky, you do not make a loan unless you offset that risk somewhere else. A borrower with a low FICO score needs a larger amount of cash reserves and probably a higher down payment, for example. Carefully underwriting to us means manually underwriting, so we have a live human being trained and skilled in looking at borrowers making these decisions.”

Two, you have to service those loans properly. That means a real relationship with the customer. Nonprime lending requires high-touch servicing enabled by high-tech in the background all while training staff to anticipate issues and help customers work though them. Most servicing operations are only set to efficiently process high volumes of perfect, on-time payments from borrowers. When that doesn’t happen for some reason, people fall through the cracks and the system crashes and burns as we saw during the foreclosure crisis.”

Three, you must provide real, actionable education. We developed an app that explains monthly payments, tax payments, insurance payments, homeowners’ association payments, and everything else so that the borrower has to repeatedly confirm what they told us about their finances is true and verify they understand what they are signing up for.”

Although critics accuse the lender of renaming subprime loans “nonprime” because the former term carries such stigma, Sharga is adamant that the loans are named something different but similar because they are designed for would-be homebuyers who need a different take on lending but this time are being served responsibly rather than haphazardly. “To call these subprime would not do these loans justice,” he declared. “These are very good borrowers and very good customers who need their loans to be managed responsibly and respectfully.” 

Straightforward Predictions for the 2018 Market

These days, Sharga continues to shape the narrative on lending and real estate from his position at Carrington. Still clearly a media favorite, he makes regular appearances on television and in other media to comment on current events and make predictions about the future.

Rick Sharga (L) talks market conditions and the lending environment with John Alkire (R), Executive Vice President of Servicing Support at Carrington.

One thing he made particular note of for 2018 in his interview with Think Realty Magazine was issues with pricing and affordability in most major metro housing markets, how these factors are affecting builder mentality and, interestingly, commercial real estate growth in these areas.

“In a lot of these hot markets you will see something of a mini-boom in construction in any area where there is room to expand or grow in a way that a developer believes will both create in-demand housing and allow a margin for profit,” he said. “Look just outside the hottest areas of the country, and you will see what are, essentially, bedroom communities going up and, in conjunction with that, commercial construction. I find that positive, because it implies there will be a growing job market in the area around the residential construction. That is different from the last housing boom.”

Sharga recommended real estate investors look for opportunity where others may have given up: in some of those “hottest markets.”

“Whether you are buying a home to rent or flipping it, there are opportunities in these high-demand, low-inventory markets. For example, there is not a lot of construction activity in San Diego or Los Angeles because it is not an option. People still want to live there, however, and investors who can find those ‘hidden’ deals are doing very good business.”

He also recommended investors look to areas with commercial construction activity, particularly building warehouses, for future growth. “As online retailers continue to command a higher and higher share of retail sales, they need somewhere to warehouse and distribute those goods. Places near hot markets become valuable distribution hubs. As employees move into the area, you will see restaurants, hotels, and office buildings pop up as well to support that population,” he said. “Multifamily construction and senior living offer opportunities in nearly every market.

“By and large, most people believe this is still a good time to buy a house,” Sharga concluded. “Furthermore, most economic indicators show we should be selling more houses than we are. The only reason we are not is because there are not more to sell, so if you have a good source of product (houses) to sell, then you’re probably going to do pretty well.”


Carole VanSickle Ellis is the editor of Think Realty Magazine. She can be reached at cellis@thinkrealty.com.